Author: Robin Wasserman
Series: Gripping Trilogy (Skinned)
Publisher: Simon Pulse/S&S
How Received: public library
When I was alive, I dreamed of flying.
Or maybe I should say: When I was alive, I dreamed.
When Auden died, Lia wasn't quite sure if she would recover. Now that she lives with Jude and his groupies - apologies, Jude and the other Mechs - she thinks that life may be good. She has credit; she lives in Quinn's huge mansion; she has the newest upgrades.
Lia doesn't trust Jude, but when he sends her in his place to pick up some of the "new" technology with Riley, she grudgingly accepts the position. But the unthinkable happens - and Lia, Riley, and the Mechs are left to deal with the consequences.
On one hand, I love this book. I didn't feel a need to put it down -- I wanted to see what happen in this world that Wasserman has created; to the characters I grew attached to in the first book of the series.
However, there are aspects of the book that annoyed me. I understand doubting your motives and the motives of those around you, and I get that it was a huge part of the plot. However, Lia seems to spend every waking moment contemplating this - and, the second her "life" gets depressing, she zones out for a month.
Stephenie Meyer-style time skip, anybody? Oh look, characters okay. Omigod, drastic event! Zone out in order to get the plot to where it needs to go. Continue writing as normal.
Also, if Lia was such an independent character the first novel, what happened to that this time 'round? Sure, she's accepted that she's a mech. It doesn't mean that she has to spend every waking moment not doing anything. If she knew the human/mech relationships were strained, why didn't she try to fix them? (Oh yeah - she was too busy zoning out because of the Depressing Event.)
[spoiler alert]
And her relationship with Riley? We've got a semi-slutty character here, folks. She goes through two guys in the first book, gets a sudden relationship with Riley in this book, while all the while denying that she has feelings for Jude. Playa!
[/spoiler alert]
The book does have it's perks. It's plot line and (albeit depressing and synthetic) world are engaging and interesting. Wasserman has a unique writing style, coming across at times as almost poetic and oh so quotable.
Overall Rating & Final Comments: I'd read it only if you really loved the first book in the series. The final rating? 7.5/10
~ N
PS: Do you like the new format? I'm trying it out.







Nice review, I agree with everything you said. I preferred Skinned over Crashed...and yes I love the new format!
ReplyDeleteGreat review. I admit skipped over parts just incase of any spoilers. (I really need to read this) I also liked how you compared it to Uglies trilogy? I'm with you, I prefer Scott Westerfeld's. :)
ReplyDeleteUgh, I haven't read Crashed yet, I'm still waiting for it from the library, but I donno... I'm not really all that excited to read it. I liked Skinned okay, but it took me a while to get into it. My best friend absolutely loved it though, so I guess I'm gonna have to give it another try. I'll have to reread Skinned before I read Crashed, anyway. And I will read Crashed, if only because I want to see if it gets any better. Sadly, your review makes me think that it will take even longer for me to get into... :(
ReplyDeleteI liked Skinned too but hmmmm... I want to read Crashed but perhaps I wont hurry.
ReplyDeleteI didnt really lioke skinned very much. I picked it up looking for something to satisfy my Scott WEesterfeld book cravings after I finished the Uglies Series, it didnt live up to ,my expectations. I might not read this book, still comtemplating...
ReplyDeleteI thinks that new format is very nice. Its a great review. you said every thing right.
ReplyDelete